Review Checklist
Correctness
- • Logic errors, off-by-one, boundary conditions
- • Null/undefined handling
- • Error handling and edge cases
- • Race conditions in async code
Type Safety
- • No
anytypes - • No non-null assertions (
!) - • No unsafe type assertions (
as Type) - • Proper generic constraints
Security
- • Input validation at boundaries
- • No secrets in code
- • Auth/authz checks present
- • SQL/XSS injection prevention
Performance
- • N+1 query patterns
- • Unnecessary re-renders (React)
- • Memory leaks (event listeners, subscriptions)
- • Large bundle imports
Maintainability
- • Clear naming
- • Appropriate abstraction level
- • No code duplication
- • Tests cover new behavior
Output Format
code
**[severity]** file:line - issue Why: explanation Suggest: fix direction
Severities: critical (blocks merge), warning (should fix), nit (optional)
Review Approach
- •Understand intent from PR description and commits
- •Check for breaking changes
- •Verify test coverage
- •Look for convention violations
- •End with: approve / request changes / comment